Descriptive Butter Mark, Acquired Goodwill & Geographical Impact : The Legal Tale of “BENNE” in Delhi

4 minutes ago
8 min read
Introduction
In the recent case of Shimow Hospitality Private Limited v. M/s Benne Delhi[1], the Delhi High Court passed an ex-parte interim injunction against the Defendant until the next date of hearing. As per the order, the Defendants were restrained from using, offering its services, marketing and advertising its business and/or allowing or permitting third parties to use, market and/or advertise the trade mark BENNE and/or BENNE Delhi and/or any other trade mark or name identical and/or similar to the plaintiff’s trademarks. The grounds of issuing such an order were that the Defendant had an intent to ride upon the Plaintiff’s goodwill as well as passing off the Plaintiff’s goods/services and trademarks and that the use of the impugned mark was detrimental to the distinctive character of the Plaintiff’s trademarks. The Court further issued a notice to the Defendants and provided them with four weeks to file their reply.
Background
The Plaintiff initiated the suit on an urgent basis due to their prior “BENNE” mark gaining formidable goodwill and reputation over a short span of time along with the acquisition of secondary meaning of their brand. After establishing their fame through plenty of documentary evidences, social media posts, news articles and so on, the Plaintiff explained various grounds of bringing this suit against the Defendant, the table from the order (page 12), explaining the arguments in favour of the Plaintiff is below for reference:

The Plaintiff’s counsel submitted that their trademarks had acquired formidable goodwill in a short span of time on account of continuous and extensive use of their prior marks. On acknowledging the descriptive nature of the mark “BENNE”, it was mainly argued that the use of Plaintiff’s

had acquired secondary meaning in the market and that the Plaintiff also adopted the following device marks:

Additionally, the Plaintiff contended that they adopted their “BENNE” marks in 2024 in classes 09, 16, 25, 35 and 43 and sought registration for the same. The Plaintiff came across the impugned mark after an internet search and found that it was adopted in April 2026 in class 43 on a “proposed to be used” basis. Based on the submissions of the Plaintiff, the Court was satisfied with their arguments and reasonings that they will suffer irreparable loss due to the use and adoption of the impugned mark.
Legal Issues
An ex-parte interim injunction in its essence is an urgent relief, so a question may arise as to what were the reasons in the present order justifying such a relief and did the reasons meet the threshold for granting ex-parte interim injunction?[2]. Further, the discussion points to the fact that the mark “BENNE” is descriptive [Benne means butter, as admitted by the Plaintiff], so is the same then being given exclusivity/monopoly to an extent that the Defendants have been granted an ex-parte interim injunction?. Moreover, assuming arguendo that Plaintiff’s “BENNE” acquired fame through secondary meaning, what aspect of of the Defendant’s marks could cause confusion in an average consumer with imperfect recollection to be deceived into believing that it is an extension of the Plaintiff’s prior “BENNE” mark? Lastly, but not the least, what were certain gaps that could have been explained by this Court better, especially in arguments (b) and (d) from the aforementioned table, to ensure that this litigation required immense (ex-parte) attention and that there was no intention of the Plaintiff to create monopoly over a culturally significant and descriptive Kannada dish?
Justification for Ex-Parte Intern Injunction of “Benne Delhi” Device Mark
As seen from the table extracted from the order above, the Court laid down that the marks are identical and deceptively similar resulting in the same visual, phonetic and conceptual impression. However, marks are to be compared as a whole and especially when they are device marks. Based on that simplicity, the device marks do not technically appear to be visually similar in any sense. Nonetheless, trademarks cannot and should not be based on a side by side comparison, rather the test of confusion: “average intelligence and imperfect recollection” on part of the consumer is the ultimate decisive factor. Since the term “BENNE” itself has gained fame in a short span of time, as claimed by the Plaintiff, the aspect of likelihood of confusion is definitely arguable but was the same properly substantiated or explained by the Court before granting the relief? The urgent interim relief may have been justified due to the Court’s discretion in granting equity as they also recorded the reasons for the same. However, in the present case, the exact reasons for why the interim injunction was ex-parte may not have been as adequately expressed.
In the case of Kumar Chadha v. Municipal Corpn. Of Delhi[3], the Supreme Court specifically mentions that a party is not entitled to an injunction as a matter of right or course and that before any Court passes such an order, it must also record the reasons for granting injunction without notice to the other side that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated by delay. However, even on a prima facie level, the Court must explain how in the present case the aspect of delay could have immensely affected the Plaintiff’s brand. The aspect of recording the reasons for such delay is not merely obligatory but mandatory for courts as was reiterated in Kailash Kumar Jain v. M/s Kundan Electro Power[4]. Moreover, the Kailash Kumar judgement also cited Hulm Entertainment Pvt. Ltd v. SBN Gamin Network Private Limited and Ors[5], wherein the Court reiterated and reproduced the principles from Dabur India[6], wherein the courts must avoid passing ex-parte ad-interim orders. The Court in the aforementioned judgment points to certain situations wherein interim orders could be given ex-parte such as in counterfeiting, distribution of spurious drugs and situations wherein there could be public harm to name a few. Nonetheless, in the present case, the Court failed to explain the sense of urgency wherein the Defendant’s reply did not seem necessary before granting an injunction especially when the situation did not call for any “public harm” as such. The Dabur India judgement does, however, acknowledge that the grant of an injunction depends on the facts and circumstances of each case. Nonetheless in the present facts and circumstances, there is minimal explanation to the harm that could be caused to the Plaintiff to an extent so high to have granted an urgent relief. [7]
An Evolved Consumer: Imperfect Recollection v. Informed Perception
An interesting point of question may be etched in point (d) of the aforementioned table by the Court wherein the classic test of consumer confusion has been satisfied in favour of the Plaintiff by the Court. The test of “average intelligence and imperfect recollection” may have been correctly placed by the Court in agreement with the submission of the Plaintiff especially due to the recognition gained by the Plaintiff’s “BENNE” in Delhi. Nonetheless, the straightjacket application of the test, without a proper justification and explanation of the same may not always serve the best possible decision especially on the assumption that an average consumer visiting such an eatery ‘knowingly’ would have certain knowledge of the food they intend to consume. When there is abundance of knowledge with the consumers at hand (which includes an average consumer), then does the uniform application of the consumer confusion test also deserve to evolve accordingly? The precedents mentioned ahead might help in understanding the answering this question.
In the case of Mountain Valley Springs India Private v. Baby Forest Ayurveda Private Limited [8], the Division Bench of the Delhi High explored the contours of a much more evolved version of the consumer confusion test which does not make the (average) consumer sound like a completely unaware person. The Court herein mentions the limitations of “Initial Interest Confusion” (IIC) test. The IIC test is basically a momentary confusion before completing the purchase of a good or service. [9] The DB in the Baby Forest order took a view which went against the strict application of the doctrine by mentioning that even an average consumer presents some sort of wonderment before purchase especially when a plethora of substantial data and resources are now available. The Court also rightfully cites from an article that “two products or services within the same general field do not automatically trigger a likelihood of confusion..” and emphasises on the same to include modern consumer behavior and sophistication rather than applying the traditional doctrine of likelihood of confusion.
Similarly in a more recent judgement by the Telangana High Court in M/S. Sal Silks (Kalamandir) Limited vs Skp B Gopinath Private Limited [10], an intriguing analysis was reiterated from the one mentioned by the DHC in the aforementioned Baby Forest case, as can be referred to from the an extract of the order reproduced below:
“It is difficult to accept that in the age of print, digital and social media, a buyer would be insulated from purchasing options. In our considered opinion, the traditional test of a person of average intelligence and imperfect recollection should shift to a perceptive consumer with informed associations - who is mindful of the source, brand, quality, comfort and aspirational - index of the proposed purchase. The earlier test no longer serves the present society; consumers are now constantly exposed to product- promotions by means of print and social media feeds on a daily basis.”
Conclusion
This case, even at this stage, especially becomes interesting because of the nature of the mark itself, the application of consumer confusion test and the subsequent relief granted to the Plaintiff. Whilst granting the relief, the Court specifically mentioned that the Defendant could not use the word mark and/or the device marks of BENNE to “offer their services” amongst other restrictions. Does the same not raise a pertinent question as to whether the Defendant has been restrained to use BENNE as a mark to even sell dosas a tad unfairly?
In the present case, although during an interim stage, the Court may not have considered the possibility of a perceived consumer as evocated in the two aforementioned cases wherein the consumer may also NOT be as affected as it was submitted by the Plaintiff. Especially when the Plaintiff’s “BENNE” gained instant fame on various social media handles, a consumer may not initially get confused but make sure which restaurant they wish to visit. The Plaintiff’s mark gained fame promptly, but that fame and reputation may have possibly tempted the Plaintiff to monopolize the generic word “BENNE”, especially when the Defendant’s device mark containing Benne was holistically different from the device mark of the Plaintiff and that BENNE is itself descriptive.
Moreover, the aspect of how a consumer is also conscious while shopping is also highlighted in the Sal Silks judgement. A consumer will not randomly purchase a product due to mere similarity. In fact, a preliminary search on the internet or an instinct to see whether what is being bought by the consumer is authentic or not is not something that can be totally omitted. The average consumer is not an absentminded or misguided individual especially when the amount of information is incomparably inexhaustive.
This is neither to say that the application of the “average intelligence and imperfect recollection” test is completely invalid nor that the Court in the present case applied the same absolutely incorrectly, but rather this case highlights a missed opportunity to reassess and reconsider the possibility of how when certain marks that have gained acquired distinctiveness may not necessarily cause likelihood of confusion in a day and age wherein the availability of resources is innumerable which provokes consumers to recheck before purchase/consumption.
Although it is arguable that the Defendant opening a BENNE named restaurant in Delhi ,wherein a “BENNE” named restaurant already exists, may create more than just initial confusion in the minds of consumers. Nevertheless, can the same be oversimplified without considering how an average yet evolved consumer may also have become more perceptive with abundance of available information? The same could have been elaborated in the present order which could establish how the test of “balance of convenience” is actually being met to grant an extreme relief at an interim level.

Arshya Wadhwa
Associate
[1] Shimow Hospitality Private Limited v. M/s Benne Delhi CS(COMM)1131/2026
[2]https://spicyip.com/2024/12/spicyip-tidbit-reasons-be-recorded-while-granting-ex-parte-injunctions-held-the-delhi-high-court.html
[3] Kumar Chadha v. Municipal Corpn. Of Delhi (1993) 3 SCC 161
[4] Kailash Kumar Jain v. M/s Kundan Electro Power FAO(COMM)196/2024
[5] Hulm Entertainment Pvt. Ltd v. SBN Gamin Network Private Limited and Ors FAO (COMM) 209/2023
[6] Dabur India Ltd. v. Emami Ltd CS(COMM) 707/2022
[7]https://spicyip.com/2024/12/spicyip-tidbit-reasons-be-recorded-while-granting-ex-parte-injunctions-held-the-delhi-high-court.html
[8] Mountain Valley Springs India Private v. Baby Forest Ayurveda Private Limited CS(COMM) 523/2023 & I.A. 5392/2024
[9]https://spicyip.com/2024/06/initial-interest-confusion-clash-forest-essentials-battles-baby-forest-at-the-dhc.html
[10] M/S. Sal Silks (Kalamandir) Limited vs Skp B Gopinath Private Limited Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 441 of 2025





























Comments